River Eagle sues Shive-Hattery claiming breach of contract, hampering project


Share
Posted Online: Jan. 03, 2013, 11:05 pm
Comment on this story | Print this story | Email this story
By Anthony Watt, awatt@qconline.com
The group planning to develop East Moline's former Case-New Holland site is suing Shive-Hattery, accusing the engineering firm of breaking an agreement and trying to hamper the project.

In 2010, the River Eagle group — comprised of Mike VanDeHeede, Matt Stern, Dan Murphy and state Sen. Mike Jacobs, D-East Moline, — bought 132 acres of the site for about $1.5 million with plans to develop it into Fountainhead of the Quad Cities, a mixed business and residential development.

River Eagle contracted with Shive-Hattery in February 2012, the suit states.

River Eagle is accusing Shive-Hattery of breach of contract and "tortious interference with business expectancy," according to the suit, filed on Monday in Rock Island County Circuit Court.

The suit accuses Shive-Hattery of breach of contract by breaking an agreement to turn over engineering and architectural work it initially had done for the Fountainhead project.

The suit alleges Shive-Hattery did not provide the services River Eagle required, so the group canceled the initial contract with the firm.

The engineering firm then filed liens against River Eagle for about $190,000, and the two parties negotiated a settlement in which River Eagle would pay $175,000 and Shive-Hattery would lift the liens, the suit states.

The engineering firm only partially lifted the liens and demanded more money, according to the lawsuit, which said afterfurther negotiation, River Eagle agreed to pay an additional $15,000, and Shive-Hattery agreed to fully lift the liens and turn over the work done on Fountainhead.

River Eagle contends Shive-Hattery has failed to turn over all of the work on the Case site as agreed.

The charge of "tortious interference" stems from accusations Myron Scheibe, office director and vice president of Shive-Hattery's Moline branch, is involved in a similar project near the River Eagle site, the suit contends.

The suit identifies that project as the RiverTech development -- a site of just more than 15 acres between 25th and 29th streets on River Drive in Moline, west of the Western Illinois University Riverfront Campus.

RiverTech would include many of the same features as Fountainhead, making it a competitor for the same kind of tenants River Eagle is targeting, the suit states.

Mr. Scheibe is accused of trying to slow River Eagle's progress through the liens and by withholding the full body of architectural work.

River Eagle is asking that Shive-Hattery turn over all the work River Eagle is owed; and for unspecified awards for the alleged breach of contract and tortious conduct and attorney's fees.

Mr. Scheibe said Shive-Hattery believes it met requirements of the agreement and intends to defend itself aggressively against what he described as a false suit.

"We categorically deny all of the allegations that are in the complaint."



















Local events heading








  Today is Friday, May 24, the 144th day of 2013. There are 221 days left in the year.
1863 -- 150 years ago: A military escort will be at the square at 9 a.m. tomorrow forthe funeral of Lieut. Joseph Eaton. The county judge is absent in Chicago, which willaccount for his not being in the procession.
1888 -- 125 years ago: Rock Island's City Council last night appropriated $95,000 forexpenses for the 1888 and 1889 fiscal year.
1913 -- 100 years ago: Mrs. F.W. Reimers last night was re-elected president of the RockIsland Musical Club at a meeting in the New Harper Hotel.
1938 -- 75 years ago: Seven members of Boy Scout Troop 21 got their Eagle badges lastnight. They were Ralph Hurt, Robert Nelson, Howard Schersten, Cecil Nelson, RobertFryxell, Clarence Stone and Rollin Hurt.
1963 -- 50 years ago: Mayor Morris Muhleman has resorted to a form letter in an effort toanswer objections to the wheel tax increase. "It was my hope that I could, in some way,restore the faith of the citizens in our city. In order to do this I knew I must face the factthat I would become very unpopular."All they are trying to do is protect the citizensproperty and build their town.
1988 -- 25 years ago: RICCA, the Rock Island County Council on Addictions, inconjunction with the Quad City Downs, will hold its annual "Night at the Races" June 2.The benefit "Night at the Races" will raise funds locally to assist in maintaining the twohalfway houses, New Hope Lodge (for women) and Beacon House (for men).




(More History)