Judge delays ruling on dismissing charges against former alderman


Share
Originally Posted Online: Jan. 04, 2013, 10:18 pm
Last Updated: Jan. 05, 2013, 3:33 pm
Comment on this story | Print this story | Email this story
By Rachel Warmke, rwarmke@qconline.com

A Scott County District Court judge on Friday delayed a ruling on a motion to dismiss a misdemeanor charge of assault while displaying a weapon against former Davenport alderman Keith Edwin Meyer.

Mr. Meyer, 71, of 1010 N. Marquette St., was charged in Scott County in connection with a Nov. 11 incident at his home in which he is accused of threatening his neighbor with a gun.

He appeared on Friday in court wearing a black suit, his salt-and-pepper hair tied into a knot on the back of his head, to represent himself during arguments over his motion to dismiss the charge.

"The question today is not whether you are guilty of the charge," Judge Cheryl Traum told Mr. Meyer, adding no witness testimony would be allowed.

Instead, the judge said the hearing on Friday was to determine whether there was sufficient information supplied in a Bill of Particulars for Mr. Meyers to prepare a defense for himself.

Mr. Meyer read aloud from court records documenting the allegations against him. He vehemently denied cursing, threatening or pointing a gun at his neighbor, shouting "not a fact" in a gravelly voice each time he read an allegation he believed to be untrue.

He further claimed police had conducted an illegal search of his home on Nov. 11 by entering uninvited. Judge Traum said she would also take this into consideration when she made her ruling as to whether the charge should be dropped.

In the meantime, the judge and Assistant Scott County AttorneyWill Ripley agreed Mr. Meyer could have any documents he had subpoenaed from the city and police department regarding the case.

Before the hearing's conclusion, Judge Traum advised Mr. Meyer to reconsider hiring an attorney.

Mr. Meyer said he wished for representation, but claimed he had problems with his past two lawyers. He indicated earlier in the hearing he was unsure whether his Social Security benefits made him ineligible for a court-appointed attorney.

"Yes, I know what I'm up against," he told the judge. "... Hey, I'm taking a risk," he said, but added he also was "taking a risk going out and hiring an attorney."

The judge had not entered a ruling on the case as of late afternoon Friday, according to the Scott County Clerk's Office.

Mr. Meyer served two terms as 3rd Ward alderman from 2003 until his defeat by Bill Boom in 2007.



















Local events heading








  Today is Friday, May 24, the 144th day of 2013. There are 221 days left in the year.
1863 -- 150 years ago: A military escort will be at the square at 9 a.m. tomorrow forthe funeral of Lieut. Joseph Eaton. The county judge is absent in Chicago, which willaccount for his not being in the procession.
1888 -- 125 years ago: Rock Island's City Council last night appropriated $95,000 forexpenses for the 1888 and 1889 fiscal year.
1913 -- 100 years ago: Mrs. F.W. Reimers last night was re-elected president of the RockIsland Musical Club at a meeting in the New Harper Hotel.
1938 -- 75 years ago: Seven members of Boy Scout Troop 21 got their Eagle badges lastnight. They were Ralph Hurt, Robert Nelson, Howard Schersten, Cecil Nelson, RobertFryxell, Clarence Stone and Rollin Hurt.
1963 -- 50 years ago: Mayor Morris Muhleman has resorted to a form letter in an effort toanswer objections to the wheel tax increase. "It was my hope that I could, in some way,restore the faith of the citizens in our city. In order to do this I knew I must face the factthat I would become very unpopular."All they are trying to do is protect the citizensproperty and build their town.
1988 -- 25 years ago: RICCA, the Rock Island County Council on Addictions, inconjunction with the Quad City Downs, will hold its annual "Night at the Races" June 2.The benefit "Night at the Races" will raise funds locally to assist in maintaining the twohalfway houses, New Hope Lodge (for women) and Beacon House (for men).




(More History)