Making Electoral College equal for all


Share
Posted Online: Feb. 23, 2013, 6:00 am
Comment on this story | Print this story | Email this story
By Kent Bush
You really find out how bad an idea was when you try to fix it.

I have always thought the Electoral College was a bad idea. It is a redistribution of voting power that defines the weight of a vote in a small state as more valuable than the same vote in a more populous state.

It also renders small states and states with a consistent voting record worthless to candidates. The Electoral College also creates the possibility that a person could win the presidency without winning the popular vote.

That's proof that you don't live in a democracy. Maybe you think a Federalist Republic is superior to a democracy.

It is.

But that doesn't mean that the Electoral College is the best way to elect a president.

Neil Freeman -- artist, urban planner and blogger -- understood that some people like the Electoral College. He also perceives that picking a president shouldn't be packed with potential problems.

His answer: Redraw the maps.

When you see the problem, it makes the solution a matter of logic. The problem is that some states are far more populous which gains them more representation in Congress and thus, the Electoral College. However, small states get one vote for their representative and two for their senators so that means small state voters are over-represented in the Electoral College.

Freeman's new map solves that. He redraws state boundaries to give each state a little over 6 million people.

Wichita would fall into a new state with Tulsa and Oklahoma City. Texas would be divided into at least five pieces.

That's right. He messed with Texas.

Hawaii becomes part of one of the Californian mini-states and Alaska joins the contiguous United States as a large, unconnected land mass. That isn't an entirely new concept for Alaska.

When you see the changes that would have to be made to make the Electoral College equitable for all voters, you can really determine the magnitude of the problem it presents.

Of course, being forced to divide New York City into several states and seeing the tiny land mass around urban areas that make up a state really help define the problem. The expanses across the western and northern United States also demonstrate how bad the solution would be.

Of course, it would never happen. Freeman isn't proposing it. He merely used his artistic abilities to show what it a solution would look like.

No one wants to redraw the boundaries for states every 10 years after a census. Who wants to see Kansas University in another state?

Only a horrible problem can have a solution this bad. The Electoral College is that bad.
Kent Bush is publisher of the Augusta, Kan., Gazette.
















 



Local events heading








  Today is Wednesday, Sept. 17, the 260th day of 2014. There are 105 days left in the year.
1864 -- 150 years ago: We are told league merchants have paid no attention to the prohibition on selling ammunition, but continue to sell just as before the order was issued.
1889 -- 125 years ago: The Rev. R.F. Sweet, rector of Trinity Episcopal Parish, left for the East to visit his boyhood home in Boston before attending the general convention of the Episcopal Church in New York.
1914 -- 100 years ago: Dr. E.A. Anderson was named to succeed Dr. E.L. Kerns as head physician of the Modern Woodmen of America, and moved to Rock Island from Holdingford, Minn.
1939 -- 75 years ago: One week late, because of the outbreak of war, Dr. E.L. Beyer resumed his work as professor of romance languages at Augustana College. Dr. and Mrs. Beyer left Germany on the last train to the Belgian border.
1964 -- 50 years ago: Employees in Turnstyle stores in Moline and Davenport will vote Oct. 2 in an election set up by the Chicago regional office of the National Labor Relations Board. Employees will vote either for the Retail Clerk International or for no union.
1989 -- 25 years ago: Rock Island High School is considering a step to help teen moms stay in school and get their diploma. The school board is expected to vote tonight on instituting an on-site child care center.


(More History)