Illinois Supreme Court debates state's Internet tax law

Originally Posted Online: May 22, 2013, 8:30 pm
Last Updated: May 22, 2013, 9:33 pm
Comment on this story | Print this story | Email this story
Illinois News Network

SPRINGFIELD — Illinois Supreme Court justices appeared skeptical Wednesday when an attorney representing the state argued the constitutionality of a two-year-old state law designed to force certain Internet retailers to collect sales taxes.

Before the law was passed, companies such as Sears and Walmart collected state sales tax on Internet transactions with Illinois customers. They did this because they had stores in Illinois, which constitutes a legal presence, or "nexus," in the state.

Companies such as Amazon, however, did not have to collect sales tax because they did not have a physical presence in Illinois.

To draw more tax revenue and end an advantage for Internet retailers, Illinois legislators redefined the term "physical presence" to include marketing affiliates based within the state – typically coupon or deal websites whose operators earn commissions for driving shopping traffic to an online retailer.

It is a novel legal concept — "a position no other court has adopted" — said George Isaacson, an attorney for the Performance Marketing Association, the plaintiff in the case. Hecontends Illinois' law goes against a requirement set by the U.S. Supreme Court in 1992 that establishes "physical presence" means having offices, branches, warehouses and employees in the state.

He said Illinois' law also violates federal statute, which has imposed a moratorium on states creating Internet-only taxes.

Illinois' law does not impose the same requirement on out-of-state businesses working with firms that place similar ads on radio or television, Isaacson said. That is evidence Internet retailers are being singled out by the law, he said.

After the law passed, Amazon dropped all of its Illinois affiliates to avoid being forced to collect the tax.

Chief Justice Thomas Kilbride expressed concern for how the law hypothetically could adversely affect a former Galesburg factory worker running an Internet-based business.

Justice Mary Jane Theis added, "We all struggle with this. We don't understand what they do enough to determine if there is nexus."

The only relationship between most Internet affiliates and companies such as Amazon or is they receive a commission for each successful sales referral they make. Justice Anne M. Burke asked ifa referral relationship created a nexus.

"No court — state or federal court in the United States — has found that that kind of limited activity is sufficient to create a nexus," Isaacson said.Assistant Attorney General Brian Barov, however, said he believed a referral relationship is sufficient to create a nexus.

About 2,000 Internet businesses left Illinois when this law passed, the Performance Marketing Association contends.

"My best guess is the state lost revenue because of this law," Isaacson said. "This is a good example of why these types of laws shouldn't be handled on a piecemeal, state-by-state basis."

The state high court is expected to issue a ruling within several months. Isaacson declined to predict its decision.

"I never make book on how courts decide cases," he said.


Local events heading

  Today is Tuesday, Sept, 30, the 273rd day of 2014. There are 92 days left in the year.

1864 — 150 years ago: The ARGUS Boys are very anxious to attend the great Democratic mass meeting tomorrow and we shall therefore, print no paper on the day.
1889 — 125 years ago: H.J. Lowery resigned from his position as manager at the Harper House.
1914 — 100 years ago: Curtis & Simonson was the name of a new legal partnership formed by two younger members of the Rock Island County Bar. Hugh Cyrtis and Devore Simonson..
1939 — 75 years ago: Harry Grell, deputy county clerk was named county recorder to fill the vacancy caused by a resignation.
1964 — 50 years ago: A new world wide reader insurance service program offering around the clock accident protection for Argus subscribers and their families is announced today.
1989 — 25 years ago: Tomato plant and other sensitive greenery may have had a hard time surviving overnight as temperatures neared the freezing point.

(More History)